Hello! We have had our loveable Frenchie Rambo since July. He is now 7m. We pee pad trained (with the Puppy Apartment that is a crate with a divider between the bed and pee pad area) since my husband and I work. It worked out well for awhile. He would sleep where is was supposed to and go potty on the pee pad where he was supposed to. But if we left him out in the pen with the doors open, he would get confused and pee on the floor. There were lots of accidents. So we decided to start the transition to outside potty training with a crate. But because he didn't have to hold it and could go when he needed to with the pee pads, he is now peeing in his crate and having accidents at night. We have been on a consistent schedule with him taking him outside, but he refuses to pee/poop outside. I know we have probably confused him by switching where he should pee/poop and we are kicking ourselves for not having taught him to go outside from the beginning. We are starting over unfortunately. Any advice would be appreciated! I know with Frenchies they can be stubborn and I have heard consistency is important. But, I can't figure out how to get him to go at least once outside so we have that potty party! He thrives on affection. So if we can get him to go and get that affection and reward, I think we'd be off to a good start! Thanks for any advice!